— Overview

This reading stays with Giotto’s innovation as they describe it, and with only the first description of Melencolia I, and they stop before later works are taken up.

Ad

— Contents and key concepts

Naturalness, against a god-centered tradition

This reading takes up a western art-history assignment that had asked, first, where Giotto’s innovation can be found, and what keyword holds it. They find the innovation in “nature,” and they take that word to mean naturalness. Medieval art, they write, was a period in which pictures and works centered on God and Christianity flowered. That method was used to carry God to people who could not read. Giotto, against that tradition, put a human breath into art, and made feeling and space that seem real on a two-dimensional surface.

The style itself, they add, pursued a natural description. It draws more sympathy from the person looking, and is at once three-dimensional and holding to the eye. The naturalness Giotto sought, they write, is like a scene that sinks into our own daily life — not a burden, and something that can be understood.

The Lamentation, a grieving face, and a blue sky

In the work they call the Lamentation, one sees Christ taken down from the cross and mourned. Mary, they write, had usually appeared only as gracious; here her expression lets one see how painful the event is, and how she is grieving. That feeling, they say, also seems to connect to the present, and is described more vividly.

Ad

Instead of choosing a sacred atmosphere of gold for the background, Giotto chose a blue sky. In place of a god-centered, formal, sanctified art, they write, he seems to be turning back toward the freer art of ancient Greece and Rome, and trying to recover a human value. Through that, they say, a Renaissance spirit looks as if it had begun to sprout.

Melencolia I, 1514, and a stop mid-look

This reading then turns to a second question: what the allegory of melancholy in Dürer’s Melencolia I suggests, and how it can be tied to the artist’s own sense of himself — of what he took himself to be. They answer only with a first look at the plate. Dürer’s Melencolia, they write, is a copper engraving made in 1514. In the picture a woman sits at the lower right, chin in hand, and wings appear to be on her back. Above her sits a small child, and the child too, they write, can be seen to have wings.

This reading breaks off there, before that allegory is carried further, and before later works named in the assignment are taken up. The same Korean report, in a longer form, sits on CampusDown.

Sources

  1. A student reading of Giotto’s Lamentation and on the opening look at Dürer’s Melencolia I, where this reading breaks off.

Last updated 15 November 2026

Frequently asked questions

Where do this reading finds Giotto’s innovation?

They find it in “nature,” which they take to mean naturalness. Medieval art, they write, flowered around God and Christianity, and used pictures to carry God to people who could not read. Giotto, against that tradition, put a human breath into art, and made feeling and space that seem real on a two-dimensional surface.

What do they see in the Lamentation?

In the work they call the Lamentation, Christ is taken down from the cross and mourned. Mary, they write, had usually been shown only as gracious; here her face lets one see how painful the loss is, and how she grieves. That feeling seems to connect to the present, and is more vividly described. Instead of a sacred gold background, Giotto chose a blue sky, turning from a god-centered, formal art toward the freer art of ancient Greece and Rome, and toward a recovery of human value — a place, they write, where a Renaissance spirit seems to have begun to sprout.

How far do they get with Dürer’s Melencolia I?

They turn to a second question, about what the allegory of melancholy in Dürer’s Melencolia I suggests, and how it relates to the artist’s own sense of himself — but they answer only with a first look at the plate. It is a copper engraving made in 1514. A woman sits at the lower right, chin in hand; wings appear to be on her back. Above her sits a small child, also with wings. This reading breaks off there, before that allegory is carried further, and before later works are taken up.

Advertisements

Found this helpful? Share it

Send it to a friend who needs it.

X Facebook Threads
Need the complete file?Total:

Refund policy

Digital files are delivered immediately after payment, so refunds are limited.
◆ Not refundable
- Change of mind / refund requested after partial use / more than 7 days after purchase
◆ Exceptions
- File errors / cannot download or open the file
◆ How to request a refund: send a 1:1 inquiry via Customer Service at the top