CampusDown

Home › Guides

Concept

Quiz or Final Exam: What's the Difference? Scriven's Formative vs Summative Assessment in US and UK Classrooms

CampusDown Editorial · 2026. 10. 28. · Updated 2026. 11. 05.
Generic AI wording will not get you ahead.Find original angles for your work on CampusDown.
Key takeaways
  • Michael Scriven coined formative and summative assessment in 1967, defining them by purpose and timing rather than format.
  • Formative assessment gathers information during learning to improve it, while summative assessment judges achievement once it is over.
  • In US and UK schools, exit tickets and Assessment for Learning sit alongside the SAT, AP and GCSE, helping students self-regulate and teachers adjust pacing.
Contents
  1. What kinds of educational evaluation are there?
  2. How did Scriven define formative and summative assessment?
  3. How do US and UK schools use the two types?
  4. Where did formative assessment start?
  5. Who benefits from formative assessment in class?
  6. FAQ

Formative assessment checks learning while it is still happening so teaching can be adjusted, while summative assessment judges what was achieved after the learning is over. The distinction comes from philosopher Michael Scriven, who coined both terms in 1967. A Friday exit ticket and a GCSE paper in June are both "tests", but they do completely different jobs. This guide compares them with real examples from American and British classrooms, from MAP Growth and the SAT to Ofsted and Assessment for Learning.

The easiest way to remember the difference is a line often credited to evaluation scholar Robert Stake: when the cook tastes the soup, that is formative; when the guests taste the soup, that is summative. Same soup, same spoon, completely different purpose.

What kinds of educational evaluation are there?

Textbooks usually list eight kinds of educational evaluation, depending on what is being judged. Formative and summative are not on the list as separate objects; instead they describe the purpose of any of them.

  • Curriculum evaluation
  • School evaluation, such as an Ofsted inspection or a US state accountability rating
  • Instructional (lesson) evaluation
  • Program evaluation
  • Student assessment
  • Teacher evaluation
  • Meta-evaluation, which evaluates an evaluation, in both formative and summative modes

So a school inspection can be formative, if it helps leaders improve during the year, or summative, if it ends in a published grade. The question is never just "what is assessed?" but "what will we do with the result?"

Ad

How did Scriven define formative and summative assessment?

Scriven introduced the terms in his 1967 essay "The Methodology of Evaluation", written about evaluating new curricula. A few years later Benjamin Bloom and colleagues carried the idea into the classroom in their 1971 handbook on formative and summative evaluation, linking it to mastery learning.

Scriven's two purposes of evaluation
TypeWhenPurposeClassroom example
FormativeWhile the activity is in progressGather information to revise, improve or patch the workExit tickets, mini whiteboards, draft feedback, hinge questions
SummativeAfter the activity has endedMake an overall judgment of effectiveness or achievementEnd-of-unit test, final exam, AP exam, GCSE paper

The key insight is that timing and purpose define the type, not the format. A quiz used only to put a grade in the gradebook is summative, even if it happens mid-unit. A past exam paper used to find which topics to reteach is formative, even though it looks exactly like a final.

Painterly illustration of an empty British school exam hall with rows of wooden desks and candidate number cards, a wall clock, and a whiteboard reading Exam in Progress, by CampusDown
Silence, numbered desks and a ticking clock: the classic setting of a summative judgment (CampusDown)

Skimming the section headings first makes a long guide much easier to map out. Try writing down one question of your own as you read.

How do US and UK schools use the two types?

Both countries are heavy users of summative testing, but they have also produced some of the strongest research on formative practice.

Summative vs formative in American and British schools
CountrySummative examplesFormative examples
United StatesState tests required under ESSA, AP exams each May scored 1 to 5, the SAT (fully digital in the US since 2024), final course gradesExit tickets, rubric-based feedback on drafts, standards-based grading check-ins, think-pair-share
EnglandGCSEs graded 9 to 1 since 2017, A-levels, end-of-primary SATs in Year 6Assessment for Learning: learning intentions, success criteria, questioning, peer and self-assessment
The grey zoneNWEA MAP Growth, given in fall, winter and spring on the RIT scale, is an interim test; it becomes formative only when teachers use the data to change instructionMock exams in Year 11 are summative in format but formative in purpose when used to plan revision

The British contribution is famous. In 1998 Paul Black and Dylan Wiliam published "Inside the Black Box", a review arguing that improving formative assessment raises standards more than almost any other classroom change. The Assessment Reform Group then popularized the phrase "Assessment for Learning", and Wiliam went on to become the best-known voice of formative assessment worldwide.

Since the 2019 inspection framework, Ofsted has also said inspectors will not look at schools' internal progress data, a signal that endless data drops are not the same thing as formative assessment.

Ad

Where did formative assessment start?

Formative assessment was born not in the classroom but in curriculum development. When teams were building a new program, they tried it out, checked how hard it was and whether it worked, and made small revisions before the final version. Only later did the idea expand into schools as a tool for improving day-to-day learning.

In other words, a tool for polishing programs became a tool for polishing learning. Remembering this origin helps: the original point of formative assessment was never to judge but to collect the information needed to fix and improve.

Who benefits from formative assessment in class?

Painterly illustration of a teacher leaning over a smiling student's desk pointing at an index card, with a board of colorful sticky notes labeled Exit Ticket on the classroom door, by CampusDown
Three minutes, one card, one question: an exit ticket tells the teacher what to do tomorrow (CampusDown)

Formative assessment carried out during a unit, a term or a school year helps two people at once.

What formative assessment gives students and teachers
For studentsFor teachers
Self-regulation: knowing where they are against the success criteriaPacing: deciding whether to move on or slow down
Diagnosis: spotting the exact step where they got stuckReteaching: identifying who needs extra help and on what
Correcting misconceptions before they hardenChecking whether the lesson design actually worked

Practical tips for teachers: write one exit-ticket question that reveals a misconception rather than one that anyone could guess; give comments without a grade on drafts, since students tend to read the number and ignore the words; and use a simple rubric so students can assess their own work. For students, treat every low-stakes quiz as free information about what to revise. That is how formative and summative assessment work as a pair: one keeps the learning on track, the other confirms where it arrived.

Reference: Scriven, M. (1967). The methodology of evaluation. In R. W. Tyler, R. M. Gagné, and M. Scriven (Eds.), Perspectives of Curriculum Evaluation (pp. 39 to 83). Rand McNally, the original source of the formative and summative distinction.

Ad

FAQ

Who came up with formative and summative assessment?

Michael Scriven introduced both terms in his 1967 essay The Methodology of Evaluation. Benjamin Bloom and colleagues later applied them to classroom learning.

Is a mid-unit quiz always formative?

No. If the result only goes into the gradebook and nothing changes, it works as summative. It is formative when the information is used to adjust teaching or learning.

Is MAP Growth formative or summative?

It is usually described as an interim assessment. It becomes formative when teachers use the results to change instruction for specific students.

What is Assessment for Learning?

It is the British approach popularized by Black and Wiliam and the Assessment Reform Group, using learning intentions, success criteria, questioning, feedback and peer and self-assessment.

What information does formative assessment give teachers?

It shows whether to adjust the pace of the lesson and which students need reteaching or extra support, and on which concepts.

Ad

Found this helpful? Share it

Send it to a friend who needs it.

X Facebook Threads