— Overview

This reading stays with those two senses and with the claim that a person is someone, not a sort, and they do not invent an official English title for the book.

Ad

— Contents and key concepts

Two senses of a word

This reading takes up Robert Spaemann’s book whose Korean title means “Why do we speak of persons.” They do not invent an official English title. The style, they write, is not always easy, but the argument keeps to one subject: the definition of person.

At the start, the meaning of the word shifts with the context, and two senses are set down. One is a headcount: person as a number of people. The other is a grammatical use of the word that expresses dignity.

Not a classifier, and not an attribute

The term person, they write, is not, unlike “human” or “man,” a mark that sorts one species from another. It is not a classificatory expression. Nor does it name some attribute that belongs to a human being.

A person, in this reading, is someone who already exists as themselves, in a form different from the other things or living beings among which they exist. This reading keeps that claim, and do not hurry past it.

Ad

Sarastro, and “I think”

Spaemann comes at another way of existing as a person through Sarastro’s well-known aria: “whoever does not rejoice in such teaching is not worthy of being human.” The line sounds like a contradiction, they write, because a person who is not a person cannot exist. That very strangeness is what the book wants to press.

They also keep Aristotle’s distinction of substance — something that is a subject of predicates, not a predicate of something else — and two kinds of change. They return to Sarastro: we understand the contradiction, this reading says, because a human being, unlike other animals, knows an inner difference, a distinction of the self. On Descartes’s “I think, therefore I am,” “I” becomes clear in the act of relating to ourselves, even if we do not know who we are or where we are. The student notes break off there. CampusDown holds the same Korean report at fuller length.

Sources

  1. A student reading of Robert Spaemann’s book whose Korean title means “Why do we speak of persons.”

Last updated 15 November 2026

Frequently asked questions

What two senses of “person” do this reading takes from Spaemann?

One is a headcount: a number of people. The other is a grammatical use of the word that expresses dignity. The book, they write, keeps to the definition of person even where the style is hard.

What does Spaemann refuse to make of the term, in this reading?

It is not a classifier that marks humans off from another species, and it is not some attribute that belongs to a human. A person is someone who exists as themselves, in a form different from other things or living beings.

Which two moments do they keep after that?

Sarastro’s aria — “whoever does not rejoice in such teaching is not worthy of being human” — a line that sounds like a contradiction, because no one who is a person can fail to be one; and Descartes’s “I think, therefore I am,” by which “I” shows itself in the act of relating to ourselves. No official English title is claimed.

Advertisements

Found this helpful? Share it

Send it to a friend who needs it.

X Facebook Threads
Need the complete file?Total:

Refund policy

Digital files are delivered immediately after payment, so refunds are limited.
◆ Not refundable
- Change of mind / refund requested after partial use / more than 7 days after purchase
◆ Exceptions
- File errors / cannot download or open the file
◆ How to request a refund: send a 1:1 inquiry via Customer Service at the top