How to Do a SWOT Analysis of a Performing Arts Department Merger: TOWS Strategies and Arts Program Cuts in the US and UK
- SWOT separates internal strengths and weaknesses from external opportunities and threats.
- A TOWS matrix pairs the boxes into SO, WO, ST and WT strategies for a department facing a merger.
- Use verified figures only and end with one priority strategy and a clear reason for it.
Contents
When a university proposes merging or closing its performing arts department, the debate quickly becomes emotional. A SWOT analysis turns that debate into structure. This guide, adapted from a Korean arts management study note, explains why performing arts programmes face mergers, what belongs in each SWOT box, how to turn the boxes into strategies with a TOWS matrix, where students usually go wrong, and how universities in the United States and the United Kingdom are facing the same pressure.
Why are performing arts departments being merged?
Several pressures overlap. Fewer school leavers means some universities struggle to fill places. Government evaluation of universities has put weight on indicators such as enrolment and graduate employment, and performing arts graduates, who often work as freelancers or on short contracts, can look weak on employment measures even when they are working in their field.
Related on CampusDown Law UpMy College Is Cutting My Major Mid-Degree. What Can I Do? — Got the email that your major is being discontinued?
The Korean source says the Ministry of Education began university restructuring evaluations in 2015, which later became the basic capability diagnosis. That history is accurate, but it needs an update: the diagnosis in that form ended after its 2021 cycle, and the government has since shifted towards accreditation-based assessment and more autonomy for universities. The underlying pressure from falling student numbers has not gone away.
"Merger" also means different things. Some universities close a department outright, but many fold several arts majors into one school or redesign them as interdisciplinary programmes. A good analysis states which scenario it assumes before it starts, because the strategies that follow depend on it.
What goes in each SWOT box?
SWOT separates internal factors, strengths and weaknesses, from external factors, opportunities and threats. Keeping internal and external apart is the most important rule, and the basic method is summarised in the wiki entry on SWOT analysis.
| Box | Examples |
|---|---|
| Strengths (internal) | Practice-based teaching that prepares students for real productions; strong team culture built through staging shows; alumni links to theatres and arts organisations |
| Weaknesses (internal) | No clear long-term vision; achievements scattered across individual productions; results hard to show in numbers |
| Opportunities (external) | Public and local arts funding; interdisciplinary teaching trends; growth of filmed performance and online content |
| Threats (external) | Ongoing university evaluation; shrinking applicant pool; few stable jobs after graduation; competition from similar programmes |
Watch for items that slip into the wrong box. "Jobs are scarce" describes the labour market, so it is a threat. "We have no careers support" is something the department can fix, so it is a weakness. The same issue lands in different boxes depending on who controls it.
Skimming the section headings first makes a long guide much easier to map out. Try writing down one question of your own as you read.
How do you turn SWOT into strategy?
Filling four boxes is only the start. The value comes from pairing internal and external factors to generate strategies, a method popularised by Heinz Weihrich's 1982 TOWS matrix.
| Strategy | Direction | Example |
|---|---|---|
| SO | Use strengths to seize opportunities | Launch a filmed-performance production track built on practical skills |
| WO | Use opportunities to fix weaknesses | Partner with local arts programmes to record and share each production's results |
| ST | Use strengths to reduce threats | Use the alumni network for placements and career links |
| WT | Reduce weaknesses and threats together | Run shared courses with related majors to cut costs and sharpen a specialism |
More strategies are not better. Rank them by what the department can actually do, then pick one or two and explain why they should come first. Thinking about where the department competes, for example by focusing on a niche, connects naturally with Porter's generic strategies.
Where do students get stuck?
- Mixing internal and external: putting "lack of government support" under weaknesses, or "staff with industry experience" under opportunities, breaks the cross analysis.
- Unsupported figures: use enrolment or employment rates only from official university disclosures; if you cannot verify a number, describe the trend instead.
- A table without a conclusion: without an answer to "so what should the department do?", the analysis is just a list.
Imagine a student who picks a drama and film major at a regional private university. Instead of writing only "practical classes" as a strength, the student finds something specific, such as staging graduation shows with a local theatre every year. Instead of a vague "fewer students" threat, the student writes that nearby universities run similar majors, so competition overlaps. This is a hypothetical example to show the method.
Before submitting, check that every item is correctly internal or external, that figures and policy names come from official sources, that all four cross strategies were considered, and that the conclusion names the first strategy to implement and why.
How are US and UK universities facing the same pressure?
United States
American colleges are bracing for a demographic cliff, as the number of high school graduates is expected to peak in the mid-2020s and then decline. Several public and private universities have announced cuts or consolidations to arts, music and language programmes in recent years, often justified by enrolment and cost data. Many departments respond with exactly the strategies above: interdisciplinary degrees, partnerships with local theatres and community arts organisations, and new tracks in digital media and arts administration.
United Kingdom
In England, the Office for Students halved the additional high-cost subject funding for performing and creative arts from 2021, and government scrutiny of so-called low-value courses has increased pressure on arts departments. A number of universities have since proposed cuts to music, drama or arts courses, prompting campaigns by students and arts bodies. At the same time, partnerships with local theatres and the creative industries remain a strong argument for keeping these programmes.
| Item | United States | United Kingdom | Korea (source country) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main pressure | Demographic cliff and costs | Funding cuts and value-for-money scrutiny | Falling school-leaver numbers and evaluation indicators |
| Typical response | Consolidation into schools of the arts | Course closures or redesign | Mergers into integrated or interdisciplinary majors |
| Strategic lever | Community and digital media partnerships | Creative industry links | Local arts funding and filmed performance |
The comparison is useful in a report because it shows that the problem is structural, not a failure of one department, and it gives evidence for which strategies have worked elsewhere.
How should you finish the report?
Related on CampusDown Law Up: My College Is Cutting My Major Mid-Degree. What Can I Do?.
A clear structure is: background to the merger debate, the department and assumptions, the SWOT table, the cross strategies, the priority strategy with an action plan, and a conclusion. In the conclusion, present the merger not only as an ending but as a possible turning point that moves the department's practical skills and community into a new teaching model, while stressing that students' right to learn and their careers must come first.
- SWOT separates internal strengths and weaknesses from external opportunities and threats.
- Who controls an issue decides which box it belongs in.
- TOWS pairs the boxes to produce SO, WO, ST and WT strategies.
- Use only verified figures and finish with a priority strategy.
- The same pressures are reshaping arts programmes in the US and UK.
FAQ
What is the most important rule in a SWOT analysis?
Keep internal factors (strengths and weaknesses) separate from external ones (opportunities and threats).
Is a lack of jobs a weakness or a threat?
A threat, because it comes from the labour market; lacking careers support is a weakness the department can fix.
What is a TOWS matrix?
A method by Heinz Weihrich (1982) that pairs SWOT factors to create SO, WO, ST and WT strategies.
How many strategies should a report include?
Review all four types, then choose one or two priorities and justify why they come first.
Can I use enrolment or employment figures?
Only figures from official disclosures; if you cannot verify them, describe the trend instead.