Does Bioethics Education Change Nursing Students? Designing a First-Year vs Third-Year Values Study
- Bioethics grew out of life-sustaining technology such as dialysis machines and ventilators, and nurses meet its questions at the bedside every day.
- Comparing first-year students with third-years who have taken ethics classes and clinical placements is a practical way to look at what education changes.
- A good study plan covers the four principles, ethics committee review, informed consent, sample size and careful wording of the results.
Contents
Bioethics education is meant to shape how future nurses reason about life-and-death decisions, and a cross-sectional study comparing first-year students with third-years who have finished ethics teaching and started placements is one of the simplest ways to explore that effect. This guide walks through where bioethics came from, why nurses need clear values, and how to design, run and report a student study properly, with examples from the United States and the United Kingdom.
A family asks the team to stop life-sustaining treatment for their father. The nurse is the person in the room most of the day, answering questions and watching how the patient responds. What should guide her? As technology makes more things possible, the gap between what we can do and what we should do keeps widening.
Where did bioethics come from?
During the twentieth century, dialysis machines, pacemakers and mechanical ventilators kept alive patients who would once have died. They also raised new questions: who gets a scarce machine first, and when is it right to stop?
Student money tip from CampusDown Life UpHow to make a simple monthly budget with the free CFPB worksheet — take-home pay, bills by due date, three spending buckets and a weekly check-in.
In the US, the 1976 Karen Ann Quinlan case in the New Jersey Supreme Court and the 1990 Cruzan decision in the US Supreme Court pushed questions about withdrawing treatment into public debate. In the same year Congress passed the Patient Self-Determination Act, which requires hospitals to tell patients about their right to make advance directives. In England, the 1993 Airedale NHS Trust v Bland ruling and later the Mental Capacity Act 2005 set the framework for decisions on behalf of people who cannot decide for themselves.
Why did nursing ethics gain its own voice?
From around the 1980s, writers increasingly stressed that nurses are not just carrying out doctors' decisions. They advocate for patients, notice distress early and often mediate between families and the medical team. That role is written into the ICN Code of Ethics for Nurses, revised in 2021, and into the NMC Code that every UK nurse must follow.
Why do nurses need firm bioethical values?
- They regularly meet end-of-life care, organ donation and reproductive decisions.
- They act as the patient's advocate when choices are being made.
- They help resolve value conflicts between patients, families and clinicians.
The major debates are summarised in the wiki entry on bioethics, euthanasia and abortion. Because ethical judgement is part of every shift rather than a rare event, practising evidence-based reasoning as a student lays the groundwork for professional growth.
Skimming the section headings first makes a long guide much easier to map out. Try writing down one question of your own as you read.
How do the four principles show up in a questionnaire?
Most bioethics value scales trace back to Tom Beauchamp and James Childress, whose Principles of Biomedical Ethics first appeared in 1979, the same year as the US Belmont Report. Their four principles are respect for autonomy, non-maleficence, beneficence and justice.
| Principle | Core idea | Nursing example |
|---|---|---|
| Respect for autonomy | Respect a person's right to decide | Explaining fully before consent, respecting a refusal |
| Non-maleficence | Do no harm | Preventing medication errors, avoiding unnecessary restraints |
| Beneficence | Act in the patient's interest | Good pain control, active health teaching |
| Justice | Share resources and burdens fairly | Prioritising care by clinical need |
An item about stopping life-sustaining treatment, for instance, probes the tension between autonomy and beneficence, while an item on choosing transplant recipients is really asking about justice. Naming the principle behind each item makes your discussion section far sharper.
How should the study be designed?
| Element | Plan |
|---|---|
| Participants | First-year nursing students with no ethics module or placement, and third-years who have completed ethics teaching and are on placement |
| Sampling | Convenience sample of students who agree after the purpose is explained |
| Instrument | A validated bioethics values questionnaire, used with the author's permission |
| Data collection | About one month |
Two hypotheses work well: students who have completed bioethics teaching differ in their values from those who have not, and values differ by clinical placement experience.
What has to happen before the first survey goes out?
Ethics review usually takes longer than students expect. In the US, research with human participants falls under the Common Rule, and the university Institutional Review Board decides whether a project needs full review or qualifies as exempt. In the UK, a student project is normally reviewed by a university research ethics committee, and anything involving NHS patients or staff goes through the Health Research Authority. Build that time into your plan from day one.
The participant information sheet should explain what the study is about, how long it takes, that taking part is voluntary, that people can withdraw at any time without penalty, and how the data will be stored and destroyed. If you are recruiting juniors from your own course, avoid handing out forms in class with staff watching. An online link shared by someone outside the teaching team removes much of the pressure.
- State the topic and hypotheses in one sentence each.
- Find a validated instrument and ask the author for permission.
- Check your institution's ethics review or exemption route.
- Finalise the information sheet, consent form and questionnaire.
- Fix the data collection window, analysis plan and reporting dates.
Permission for the instrument is the step people forget. Published scales are often copyrighted, and translating or editing items without permission can sink a project late in the term. A short email to the author early on usually solves it.
How many students do you need?
Comparing two year groups only works if each group is big enough. Free tools such as G*Power calculate the required sample from your significance level, power and expected effect size. Add a margin for incomplete or careless responses before you set your recruitment target.
How do you analyse and report the results?
Use an independent samples t-test to compare the two year groups' mean scores, ANOVA to look at differences across general characteristics such as age or religion, and correlation to see how variables relate. If statistics software feels unfamiliar, your university's maths and stats support service can help, and it is a good place to learn how to lay out results tables in APA style.
Value surveys are prone to social desirability bias, where people pick the answer that looks right. Guaranteeing anonymity and writing neutral items reduces it, and one sentence acknowledging the limitation makes your report more credible. Pilot the questionnaire with a handful of students first to catch confusing wording, double-barrelled questions and leading phrasing.
If the third-years score differently, link the gap to the curriculum. Did placements change how they weigh a particular principle, or was it the ethics module? Because a cross-sectional study does not follow the same students over time, write that the groups differed rather than that students changed.
How should you finish the paper?
Close with limitations and next steps. A single-school sample limits generalisation, and a longitudinal study following one cohort from first to third year would show the effect of education more clearly. For the theoretical background of the profession, the wiki page on nursing theory is a useful companion.
Student money tip on CampusDown Life Up: How to make a simple monthly budget with the free CFPB worksheet.
A few honest sentences about what your data can and cannot show make a student project read like real research. CampusDown's nursing report collection has more worked examples of research designs like this one if you want to compare structures before you write.
Reviewed by the CampusDown editorial team, November 2026. References: Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F., Principles of Biomedical Ethics (first edition 1979); The Belmont Report (1979); ICN Code of Ethics for Nurses (2021); NMC, The Code (2018).
FAQ
Is bioethics the same as nursing ethics?
No. Bioethics covers moral questions across medicine and the life sciences, while nursing ethics focuses on the nurse's professional duties, set out in codes such as the ICN Code of Ethics for Nurses and, in the UK, the NMC Code.
Does a student survey project need IRB approval?
Usually it needs some form of review. In the US the university IRB decides whether a study is exempt under the Common Rule, and in the UK a university research ethics committee reviews it. Students should not decide exemption for themselves.
What is convenience sampling?
Recruiting the people who are easiest to reach, such as classmates in one school. It is quick, but the results cannot be generalised to all nursing students.
Which test compares first-year and third-year scores?
An independent samples t-test compares the mean scores of two separate groups. Use ANOVA for three or more groups and correlation to look at relationships between variables.